Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. His theory distinguishes law from facts and morals. The pure theory of law destroys this dualism by replacing it with a unitary system of objective positive law that is insulated from political manipulation. Though the first exposition of theory took place in 1911, it came in full bloom in. The whole of chapter 3 of pure theory is devoted to insisting that the pure theory is a true science. There are familiar questions connected with explaining legal. Consists of nine essays by various scholars concerning pure sociology generally and the theories of law and social control more specifically. It is of the view that law is a system of norms accepted by the society to be binding. Science was generally the domain of the causal understanding of epistemological data and its primary logical and causally oriented technique was to be distinguished from the normative reasoning as was.
A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the. The economic analysis of law stanford encyclopedia of. The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Accordingly, the term natural law denotes a natural order of things. To view the pdf, you must log in or become a member. As a theory it is exclusively concerned with the accurate definition of its subject matter. This is important because different disciplines have different methodology, and so its hard to analyse law when its all mixed up with other things. Kelsens book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. Its purpose is to purify the traditional science of law by removing from it the many foreign elements whuch have found their way into it, and thus to establish a pure method of legal cognition. It is a general theory of law, not an interpretation of specific national or international legal norms.
Human laws are posits of human society while scientific laws are independent of what we take them to be. Hans kelsons pure theory of law is a part of analytical positivism. It is characterized as a pure theory of law because it aims to focus on law alone. Kelsen is most famous for his studies on law and especially for his idea known as the pure theory of the law. This essay first sets out the epistemological basis of the pure theory in cognition of the law, that is, on how exactly law is perceived and recognized. Email citation a symposium reflecting on black 1976 cited under the theory of law. Kelsen divides his pure theory between a theory of law in its state of rest, which focuses on law as a system of norms, and a theory of law in motion, which focuses on the processes by which legal norms are created. International law does not fit in the pure theory of law. Each of these norms trace their validity to a higher norm until it gets to the grundnorm. The pure theory of law maintains that laws are norms handed down by the state. He released the theory of law entitled the general theory of law and state 1945.
The pure theory of law states that the law does not seek to describe what must occur, but rather defines rules that individuals have to abide by. Since the pure theory of law does not pretend that its definition refers to just law but only to what usually is and always was termed law, since the pure theory of law is not interested in knowing whether the law as defined by it is law in the specific sense mr. The main ingredients of kelsens pure theory are derived from kants theory. Positive law is a reaction against particularly that aspect of natural law theory.
The pure theory describes the positive law as an objectively valid order and states that this interpretation is possible only under the condition that a basic norm is presupposed. Pure theory of law defines law as a system of coercive norms created by the state that rests on the validity of a generally accepted grundnorm, or basic norm, such as the supremacy of the constitution. May 19, 2016 international law does not fit in the pure theory of law. Conclusionsthe pure theory of law and contemporary positivism. Kelsens pure theory can be said to be one of the most refined developments of analytical positivism.
Blacks theory of law and social control criminology. So, this post is not just about the pure theory of law, but to also prove it as the most acceptable theory of all. Kelsen was a professor at vienna, cologne, geneva, and the german university in prague. Kelsens pure theory of law kelsen intends his pure theory of law to serve as a general account of the nature and function of law.
Hans kelsen was a european legal philosopher and teacher who emigrated to the united states in 1940 after leaving nazi germany. Many of the criticisms directed against the pure theory do rest, indeed, on what is perceived as its aridity and seperation from the realities of legal activity within the community. The whole of chapter 3 of pure theory is devoted to insisting that the pure theory is a. However, whether, why and how we ought to respect the natural law are questions that we cannot address sensibly before we have a clear idea of what the natural law is. It attempts to answer the question what and how the law is, not how it ought to be. Other articles where pure theory of law is discussed. An economics law that suggests that the existence of excess supply in one market must be matched by excess demand in another market so that it. This paper deals with the basic causes of numerous often extremely negatively intoned critical estimations said on the account of kelsons pure theory of law and exposes essential properties of certain phases of its development. The theory thus applies to any existing legal system. The pure theory, thereby characterizes this interpretation as possible, not necessary, and presents the objective validity of positive law only as conditional. For that reason, it should be taken as a limitation of the theory.
This theory of law is led by professor hans kelson. Pure theory of law kindle edition by kelsen, hans, knight. The pure theory of law is a theory of positive law. Dec 08, 2014 the theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. It argues that the pure theory is best understood as an attempt to find a middle ground between natural law and legal positivism that may serve to reconnect positivist legal thought in a distinctive and so far unexplored way with normative political theory. A continuities symposium on donald blacks the behavior of law. Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. This concluding chapter once again takes up the question of what form of legal theory we find in kelsen. This is the essence of legal positivism, in contradistinction to the natural law doctrine. Hans kelsen, austrianamerican legal philosopher, teacher, jurist, and writer on international law, who formulated a kind of positivism known as the pure theory of law. In chapter three of pure theory of law, law is defined as the application of norms to its functions within the delineations of a science of law.
Pure race legal definition merriamwebster law dictionary. Hans kelsen on international law francois rigaux abstract kelsens monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is a positivist theory that has been enormously influential in the world of jurisprudence. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the formidable austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 see the bibliographical note. The easiesttoread, most userfriendly guide to legal terms. Rather, his aim was to present law as it is, free from all the various ideologies. It insists on a distinction between human law, which they call positive law and moral and scientific laws. Kelsen began his long career as a legal theorist at the beginning of the 20th century. Pure theory of law meaning and proving as the most. The grundnorm kelons pure theory of law is based on pyramidical structure of hierarchy of norms which derive their validity from the basic norm which he termed as grundnorm. The pure theory of law is only helpful to legal scientist. As such, kelsens pure theory attempts to examine and define what law is outside the purview of these normative areas.
Kelsons pure theory of law according to kelson a theory of law should be uniform. Kelsens pure theory of law is unanswerable, but that its substance is an exercise in logic, not in life. Contribution of thetheory pure theory of law enriched jurisprudence. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by co. Pure theory of law meaning and proving as the most acceptable. Pdf kelsens pure theory of law naveed hussain academia. Rechtslehre and translated into english as pure theory of law in 1967. Thus, this definition defines law as a set of rules to be followed by everyone, regardless of their stature. The remainder of the norms are associated by inferior norms, when one is contrasted with another 4. Kelsens pure theory allows for a pure legal science. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by corelating it with all social sciences and rigorously. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. Under the natural law theory, only laws that are just are to be followed, while unjust laws may.
Hans kelsens pure theory of law by tim murphy ssrn. Pdf visualization of hans kelsens pure theory of law. Kelsen was born in prague, czechoslovakia, on october 11, 1881. Possibly the most influential jurisprudent of the twentieth century, hans kelsen 18811973 was legal adviser to austrias last emperor and its first republican government, the founder and. Thus, grundnorm or basic norm determines the content and gives validity to other norms derived from it. The jurist and legal philosopher hans kelsen coined the term to refre to the fundamental norm, order, or rule that forms an underlying basis for a legal system. A natural law theory, in so far as it concerns human affairs, attempts to explain both what the natural law of the human world is and why and how we ought to respect it. Though the first exposition of theory took place in 1911, it came in full bloom in postwar europe. In defining the law as a coercive order the pure theory of law conceives of the law as a specific social technique.
Economic analysis of law is not a single, unitary practice but a set of projects that share a methodological approach. The grundnorm is the norm from which other norms get their validity. Pure theory of law law and legal definition uslegal, inc. A symposium reflecting on black 1976 cited under the theory of law. Out of the multiple theories of law, i personally do love the pure theory of law. Kelsen distinguishes his pure theory of law from both traditional natural law theory and traditional legal positivism, and instead identifies his theory as a middleway between the two traditional theories. Glos the normative theory of law came into existence earlyim the twentieth century. A legal system is an interconnected system of norms, in which coercive techniques are used to secure compliance. What are the mains points of criticism of this theory. Possibly the most influential jurisprudent of the twentieth century, hans kelsen 18811973 was legal adviser to austrias last emperor and its first republican government, the founder.
It should be applicable to all times and in all places. An economics law that suggests that the existence of excess supply in one market must be matched by excess demand in another market so that it balances out. Laws are not defined in terms of history, ethics, sociology, or other external factors. John austins law definition states law is the aggregate set of rules set by a man as politically superior, or sovereign to men, as political subjects. Hart, and many other legal theorists of the past century1 is the idea that law is a normative system, and that any theory about the nature of law must focus on its normativity. The validity of each law, or legal norm, is traced to another. It deals with the existing fact for example what law is and not as it ought to be. The validity of each law, or legal norm, is traced to another legal norm. Hence, the theory is more so given in terms of formation of hierarchical laws commencing from basic norm. Kelson explains his theory by the method of analogy. Kelsen calls his theory as pure theory of law as it attempts to distinguish between law and what is not strictly law.
Natural law theory is a legal theory that recognizes a deep connection between the law and morality. The thomist point of view is important to this paper, because it establishes a basic difference between it and another study of kelsans pure theory of law already made. Rather, it addresses a specific question about the causes or consequences or social value of a specific legal rule or. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960 the theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. The pure theory of law is termed as theory of positive law.
Hence, kelsen propounded the idea of a pure theory of law, which is a theory of positive law. Translation from the second german edition by max knight. Grundnorm law and legal definition grundnorm is a german word meaning fundamental norm. Reine rechtslehre is a book by legal theorist hans kelsen, first published in 1934 and in a greatly expanded second edition effectively a different book in 1960. With his pure theory of law, hans kelsen did not wish to present any new ideology of law. Or kelson wishes to free the law from the metaphysical mist which it has been covered of all times. Hans kelsen normative theory grundnorm jurisprudence. The pure theory of law which is also known as vienna school of legal thought was propounded by hans kelson, a professor in vienna austria university. The typical economic analysis of law does not set its task within the framework of a general legal theory.
1200 273 567 1144 36 1442 169 1533 319 180 514 1105 306 1155 402 359 711 663 404 479 785 23 340 876 926 643 666 945